When Bigger is NOT Better
All Posts, Marketing, Trucks|American car manufacturers have been accused of being slow to react to the market. I remember having a conversation with a friend who was a former employee of Sargummi (They do all the little bits of rubber around the windows for GM). He basically made the point that in his opinion the US-Auto machine tended to be single minded and lacking in vision. Not really new news is it?
What is interesting is the historical correlation between now and the 1970/80s:
- the current increase in oil prices
- the trend of American manufacturers to build increasingly larger and larger vehicles
- the foresight of Asian car manufacturers
Case in point is the news that SUV sales sales for GM have dropped by 50% (GM Sales of SUVs Plummet 50 Percent @ Media Buyer Planner). This is interesting for two reasons. Firstly at a time that sees dwindling fossil fuel reserves, GM/Ford etc are all still pushing larger and larger vehicles. Size that no-one really needs or increasingly wants. I still remember my first trip to the USA and upon seeing an F350 dual wheel monster drive past with a wheel barrow, cement mixer and some bricks in the tray, thinking “Is a load of bricks really that much heavier here?” Back in OZ the same load was usually handles by a 4 pot turbo diesel Toyota.
The second thing is that perhaps people are finally realising that they don’t need a V8 SUV to get to the shops and ferry the kids to school.
The article states:
Merrill Lynch auto analyst John Casesa said GM’s plummeting SUV sales may hint at low numbers for upcoming launches. “We are growing increasingly concerned about all the prospects of GM’s new line of SUVs,” he said.
Meanwhile, Toyota Motor Sales USA, American Honda Motor Co., Nissan North America, and Hyundai Motor America all posted increased sales in September.
Is bigger better? Well if you look at sales volume, environmental impact, fuel consumption and real world driving requirements; then the answer is “No”.

October 6th, 2005 at 6:00 pm
Yes, but a Ford F-350 Duallie just LOOKS sooooooo coooool…..
Makes me feel like a manly man! [ pounds chest ]
October 6th, 2005 at 9:17 pm
Personally I’m a short wheelbase, monster tyres kinda guy… even though I drive a 3.4L Toyota 4Runner.
BTW, the runner has outclassed more than one F-100 and Jeep on the trails and bogs around here.
October 7th, 2005 at 7:27 am
Runner is a great truck! I should clarify I own an F-150, not a F-350 Duallie, but that IS my dream truck! ;-P Down here in my parts of FL (by the everglades), the swamp buggy and airboat rules all….you should see what some park rangers are driving here…
October 7th, 2005 at 7:50 am
Hey Frank,
Did you get your CafeGeek t-shirt yet? I priority mailed them all last week… Send me an email with a pic of you wearing it when you do eh?
I wanna build up my little truck into something like this:
http://digilander.libero.it/EndRoad/immagini/toyotas/Toyota%204runner‘%20bianco.jpg
While I would loooooove a big SWB F250 with 44″ Swampers, they pretty much suck on tight trails. Horses for Courses I guess….
October 7th, 2005 at 3:11 pm
There is a difference between appreciating beauty and owning beauty.
I can look at an orchid and appreciate its beauty. Should I pluck it and endanger the species? No.
In analogy, I can admire a Ferrari or all those 4WD you guys talk about. Do I really need one and endanger our planet? Certainly not. And don’t get me started about the need to own a car at all, which I don’t.
Contrary to what society and governments want you to think, we do not need to own in order to be pleased.
October 9th, 2005 at 1:00 pm
You’re such a hippy Hector!!! And I love you for it. It’s people like you that counter balance people like Frank and I.
What also needs to be considered is the geographical size of a place like Canada, the USA or Australia. It’s one thing to not have a car in Europe, where one can cross 3 countries in a day in a bus, as opposed to somewhere like where I live.
The nearest University, my University, is 100km away.
The nearest airport is 220km away.
The nearest big city 300km.
My work, 5km with no public transport (though I usually try to cycle)
To get the company mail, a daily job, is a 30km drive.
Our production plant is a 25km drive.
Having said that, living in a city (Paris, Montreal, NYC, Sydney, Tokyo, Hong Kong) there is an adequate public transport system and a car is a luxury for most.
October 10th, 2005 at 2:22 am
Oh, I agree with you completely! It does make sense to own a car in countries like Canada, Sweden, or Australia (?). And back that up with a 4WD, because there is a real use for it.
I whined because your post talked about mentality towards oil (nice post), but the comments deviated into manly pride
I take hippy as a compliment
February 11th, 2007 at 11:10 am
Hello, my name is Alex, i’m a newbie here. I really do like your resource and really interested in things you discuss here, also would like to enter your community, hope it is possible:-) Cya around, best regards, Alex!